After taking a break today I went back and looked at it one more time and got it! I feel like such an idiot, made such a huge fuss and spent so much time over nothing. IT WASN'T GROUNDED. Can't believe I hadn't checked that. Thank you guys for all of the suggestions, at least I got to know pretty much every wire that's on my bike haha.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Motorcycle.com App
1985 Honda Shadow VT500